I found this product pretty good, might smuge a little though. Over all not bad and not too expensive either.

didnt really like it, smeared and just looked like crap didnt last long

I am not a big fan of this eye liner I find it smudges easy and wears off quickly. I will not buy it again

This is an average eye liner at a good price. It goes on smooth and lasts about 6 hour before it starts flaking off.

I have bought these eye liners many times hoping to have better luck. I agree with some of the other reviews in that the twist up feature is easy to use, not messy etc. but as far as my experience with them, it has not been good. For some reason, they will not go on my skin with good coverage. I have to keep applying it over and over. Then hours later, it looks as if I do not even have any on. The first few purchases I thought ok, I have a dud! I have also had the lid split and come off in the makeup bag I carry in my purse. Then it worked! Eyeliner inside the makeup bag and all over the makeup in the bag. Sadly I cannot recommend these and do not plan on buying any anytime soon!

The liner itself went on very smoothly, but the problem lies in the "glimmer" it eventually clumps and prevents the liner from getting on anything. The glimmer after it "clumps" is very painful on the eyelid as well it doesn't leave any liner whatsoever, defeating the purpose of using it. At first use, it was amazing but after that not so much. The color itself on the stick with the glitter looks pretty, but unless you want to press super hard on your lid it doesn't come off properly.

Ugh... I have tried to like these a few different times hoping I would get a good one. Sure they are cheap, but they are not worth the hassle. They do not go on smoothly, rather they tug and leave either no colour or big gobs of it.