Not a fan

I received this in a boxy charm and was excited to get a liner that was brownninstead of black. I was so disappointed when I tried it. It had a weird smell and texture and did not apply will at all on the eyes. The color was a fount muted Brown as well.

Not good.

This eyeliner says it can be so many things (eyeshadow base, brows, eyeliner) and honestly it fails on all of them. As an eyeliner, it's patchy and doesn't show up well. I haven't used it as an eyeshadow base, but It's so patchy I can't imagine it would be any good. I have used it on my brows and It's just not the right color, however brows might be this products saving grace. It is more of a brow pomade than anything else. Over all I could find 3 better products at the drugstore for the cost of this one item ($22).