I was recently given this mascara by a friend who ,I believe, got 2 from this site.
The first thin i noticed was the smell. It isn't very pleasant and is a little strong at first but I was able to get past it when I put it on.
I was really pleased with the results, it gave me really long and defined lashes. I did find myself having to wipe some of it off the comb before applying it because it was a little much and left a few minor clumps.
I got used to the smell and it didn't stay with me all day so it wasn't a big deal.
I really like this and have been using it a lot, i admit the price is high for me and I would not have used this had I not been given it for free. If i had more money to spend I likely would buy this because I loved the way it made my lashes look.