For the price of this product it works very well. It creates nice lines that are long lasting!

I'm not sure if I got some that were old and had been sitting on the shelves for a long time or what, but this stuff was sucky. It didn't work very well. The line wasn't strong and I ended up finishing with another product. Weirdly enough though, e.l.f.'s eyeliner that is pretty much identical to this but it's not waterproof, is great for the price! I'm convinced I got a bad batch or something, but I'll just stick with the not waterproof version.