I got this item because it was on sale. That and the oil-free had me hooked. The first time I tried them I had an almost slimy residue on my face and neck (I wear foundation on my neck to match my face). I thought it could just have been a fluke. Turns out it's not. Aside from that they work great. They smell fresh and remove makeup easily, with the exception of my waterproof mascara. I will definitely use these towelettes until they are gone but I have the feeling there is a better product out there somewhere.