Cute package but ineffective

I received the Hello Fresh Deodorant this week to trial. Having used various brands of natural deodorant I was hopeful this one would be a winner, but unfortunately the product did not work as effectively as I had hoped especially with the charcoal
Initially I smelled great and felt fresh, but as the day went on (4pm) I began to notice a sour smell. By evening I wanted to take a shower to smell clean again.
The product was hard to initially use due to the bottom wind being very difficult to use. Once the stick was up it went on smoothly and wasn't overly sticky which was nice. It was slightly abrasive so if I had any irritation that would be an issue. I tried the product both with unshaved and shaved armpits to see if there was a difference in effectiveness - it didn't matter and was unfortunately ineffective either way.
I gave the product an entire week and a half exclusive use just to see if my body needed to adjust but it didn't improve.
Good try Hello, I hope I am the exception to the general population :)

Disappointed :(

I received this about over a week ago and began using it about twice a day once in the morning and before night after each shower. I’m giving it 2 stars because in the past week I did notice some rashes, redness and bumps which was quite shocking to me as it’s aluminum free which is what I usual look for when purchasing deodorants. It was disappointing for somebody who always purchases natural and safe ingredient products :( In terms of performance this deodorant for the most part was long lasting and did keep odour and sweat out from my underarms for an entire working day (7 hrs). On black clothing it did show small amounts of whitish residue but scent was perfectly normal as it wasn’t strong. I did enjoy the scent! Also packaging was good as it was easy to roll up and down while the product didn’t get crushed or soften. I probably wouldn’t purchase this product as it seems like I am allergic to an ingredient in this deodorant.