Love the Brand, Dislike this type

I have been using the Volumious Mascara for a couple years now and I have always loved it! It was light, easy to remove, no clumps!
I decided to try the waterproof carbon black type this time!
Worst mistake I made!
This mascara is impossible to remove without basically pushing your eye out! It is so heavy and clumps on thick!
I will never buy this mascara again.

Will never buy this again.

I purchased this mascara from a local Shoppers after seeing the ad in one of my magazines and I needed more mascara. This stuff sucks! This is the clumpiest mascara I have ever used. You have to wipe off the brush before each use because the mascara wand comes out covered in gobs of black liquid. I know not to use old makeup products so that cannot be the problem! I recently bough another brand, so this crap can go in the garbage!

Just your average mascara

I once purchased this product when it was on sale... It wasn't amazing but I would consider repurchasing if there was a good deal on it! I also suggest the waterproof kind

I would not buy this product again

This product is okay but for me it is too thick and when I apply to my eyelashes I have to follow up with a different mascara immediately after so the lashes are separated and not clumped together

Pas le meilleur

Je n'ai pas vraiment trippé sir ce mascara, j'ai l'impression qu'il fait beaucoup de grumaux et qu'il ne donne pas assez de volume à mes cils. Je dois en mettre beaucoup pour que ça fasse de l'effet. Mais ce n'est pas le plus pire mascara non plus.

This is definitely an affordable mascara on the cheaper end but I don't find it to be effective for me as it claims. Supposed to be voluminous but I just find it clumpy. There are other cheap mascaras out there that does the job better.

I accidentally bought this instead of the Carbon Black mascara, and I really don't think it's worth a purchase. I just ended up clumping my lashes together into 5 spider legs. It also didn't add any length. While it's not absolutely horrible, and it may work for other lashes, I wouldn't recommend this at all.

I bought this mascara based on all the good reviews, unfortunately for me it just clumps my lashes all together no matter what I do. Definitely not my favorite mascara.

I bought this mascara based on many positive reviews, but it really did not work for me. It did provide quick volume, but the flaking and clumping/spider lashes were terrible.

As a disclaimer, I do admit to disliking fiber brushes in general, but I has a particularly bad experience with this mascara (especially considering this is in the higher price range for a drugstore mascara).

This mascara for ME...was too clumpy!!! I tried so many times to love it, but it never worked out for me...

However, maybe if you combine it was a lash primer before it might help to reduce how clumpy it usually gets?