Not impressed

I usually love l’Oreal but this mascara didn’t do it for me. Takes forever to dry and doesn’t give my lashes the volume and lenght that other mascara does.

Falls off lashes.

I was loving the spooly for this it did make my eye lashes look nice but after an hour or two of wearing it started just breaking off resulting in my eyes becoming very itchy and almost couldn't even open them

A second option mascara

I'm looking for a great mascara as I always get a bad one because of its formula. When I tried this mascara, the brush was so cool and easy to use to apply to curled eyelashes. The colour black is nice and it really adds volume to the eyelashes. After wearing the mascara for about an hour, it started bleeding on my eyebags, and I noticed that it was clumpy. I think something is wrong with the formula. I'm not sure if I will use this mascara again.

Okay but eh

It went on smooth but I feel like it could have done more. It didn’t feel like it did enough to my eyelashes and didn’t make them pop as much as I wanted them to. For something that’s supposed to be voluminous it definitely fell flat

I like it

I like the mascara for my bottom lashes does not give me length only volume which is why I only use for bottom I still like this mascara and would use it

Decent.

As the headline says, this mascara is decent. But "decent" mascaras seem to be a dime a dozen in the drugstore world! I used it with liquid eyeliner, which tends to swallow up any mascara that doesn't give plenty of volume... so I'm curious what this product will do on a simpler look without eyeliner. I prefer plastic applicators, so this one feels a bit archaic to me (that could also be because this is a OG mascara and I remember it from when I was a teenager). Nothing wrong with the formula, it's just not what I look for in a mascara.

Not even ‘meh

I was not even mildly impressed with this mascara. It was thick and clumpy and the fallout was unbelievable. Not sure if this was a bad batch but I will not be purchasing this mascara again.

disappointing

This has been my mascara of choice for several years, but the last few times I have purchased it after just a few uses it starts to clump on the wand and does not apply well. I now will have the dollar spending task of trying to find a mascara that works well for me.

Good when New

It's AMAZING when its new. It gives you long, full and bold lashes. About a month or so it's just....not good. It clumps, dry and just smudges. Considering you should toss out your mascara around 3 months this isn't ideal. It does go on sale rather often for about $7-8 which is a steal, but it's just not long lasting. I'd rather buy another brand to be honest.

Sorry, but no

I was so excited to try this out when I heard that it was the #1 selling mascara in Canada. How had I not tried it yet? It cost a few dollars more than the drugstore brand that I would buy if I am going with a drugstore brand and not my Sephora go-to, but it was worth a shot. I couldn't believe how clumpy it was, almost immediately! The brush was always blobby, dry, and the formula was not smooth at all, right off the bat.bit made my lashes stick together and did absolutely nothing for the volume. I don't know if the store was selling old stock or something but it was bad enough that I don't even want to spend the money giving it another try. For all the hype, I just don't get it. And I recommend that you don't get it, either.