Very clumpy, doesn't provide the length desired. There's only volume because of them clumps.

Easy to apply, black is very black and will makes your eye lashes pop. Only downside it's not that waterproof

makes your lashes so long and thick love it!!!

I love L'Oreal mascaras. I use the waterproof version in black. I find it stays on better than some of the more expensive mascaras I have worn. The mascara sometimes builds up on the applicator, causing clumping, but once you wipe it clean, it's back to normal!

What a wonderful mascara that shows a big difference!

This mascara was a waste of money but thankfully i could return it. to get the desired / advertised effect, i would have had to apply at least 3 coats. i dont have time for that!!

This is my best EVER! Miss manga rock is a very good mascara to make your lashes long and thick. It as always been one of my basic product I use everyday. It is effective and so beautiful! I love it. Look at my picture!

This product does exactly what it says it will do. You get thick clumped looking rocker lashes. I had to try it but after decided that wasn't the look I wanted. Goes on nice and dark, brush is small & nice for lower lashes.

This product gives lots of volume to lashes. It is a great price, it can be about $13-15. It works really well to extend lashes, and has a sleek brush. I recommend it for anyone who has short lashes. It really makes your eyes pop!

I just bought this mascara as it seemed like a great product and I love L'Oreal. My eyes are very sensitive to certain types of voluminous mascara so I get scared every time I try a new one. The brush is interesting as it is 360 degrees and the spikes are uneven and bigger gaps in between. I found that it gave me the effect that I was looking for and the effect that it promised. I found myself a new mascara and I couldn't be happier with it! :)