I love this eyeliner! It goes on smoothe and lasts forever. you have to make sure you close the lid tight otherwise will dry out quickly.

Love this product! No mess when you put it on :-)

super easy to apply and stays on really well all day!

This is brilliant, I haven't returned to using liquid eyeliner since getting this as a present. It is easier to apply than liquid and the buildable colour means it's more day-friendly than liquid as well. It also feels comfortable on my eyes and the consistency I find is really good. I had a Calvin Klein liquid liner before and I had to paint it on for ages to get an even colour. I love this

just started to use this, and its GREAT price is a bit much... but its great

I think this eyeliner is definitely one of my favourites! I Love everything about this eyeliner. I have very oily skin so when I tried this I was a little anxious to see if it would stay. AND IT DID. The smooth consistency allows for easy application which helps, especially when making wings on your eye lids. This is my go to product for an all day event, school, and everyday occasion. It doesn't smudge or flake. The only downside that it requires a bit more time to put on when compared to a pencil or ink eyeliner. Other then that it is a good find. (:

You have to buy this! I will never waste my time with a mass-market line again. This does not smudge or smear to the upper lid of your eye! and the colour! It is perfect. The black is a true, deep back!

Make sure you get a nice angle brush to compliment this and use it effectively!

Love this product (would love it even better if I could apply it once instead of 4 times, lol). It lasts forever (doesn't dry out), is easy to use, stays on all night (haven't noticed any flaking or anything) and has a great consistency. Very much recommend this product!

This is definitely a good product. MAC always has great quality makeup and this eyeliner is no exception. My only judgement is that I just don't find this product very convenient. I prefer using the liquid eyeliner rather than buying a pot of the Fluidline and using a separate eyeliner brush. However, aside from that, it's a good product.

Love everything about this eyeliner. Has amazing staying power on my oily skin. The smooth consistency allows for easy application. You can create a graphic eye look or also smudge it out for a more natural finish. This is my go to product for an all day event. It doesn't smudge or flake. The only downside that it requires a bit more time to put on when compared to a pencil or ink eyeliner.