overpriced for the name.

i literally live for liquid eyeliner, it's my best friend. every.single.day.
i was told about this product a few years ago and thought "hey, absolutely i'll try it"
we already know MAC is expensive so i knew that walking into the store. i bought it, went home and tried it.
god i was so disappointed. the product sucks! it's not at all dark (how i like my makeup) and i had to shake the bottle for liquid to come onto the stick. this product isn't worth the price.

Not black enough and hard to use

You have to shake the bottle to get the color to be black. Or else you'll get a runny grey consistency. the brush is good for laying the basic color in between the lashes to get a thick liner look. But not ideal for the thin eyeliner look. If you want a thin line with this, the brush is quiet bulky for the look so it will take longer to do your thin eyeliner. I'm don't get oily but I do notice the line smudge a bit at the end of the day. Also it is terribly difficult to remove it after, i use 2 mac makeup wipes. not a good sign

I have pretty much tried A LOT of different branded eyeliners - from pencil -gel - liquid. I have never found one that satisfied my needs. Even though it was waterproof, the eyeliner will never last all day. About a few years ago, I came upon liquidlast eyeliner and all I have to say is AMAZING. It lasts for all day and smudge-free. The only thing is you require an intensive makeup remover to remove it - Vaseline always work!

This product is not the cheapest thing around the corner and isn't really worth. I feel that you are paying more for the brand name than the actual product itself. Could definitely say there are drugstores products that would just as good even better, to be honest.

I love this liquid liner. I previously ONLY used MAC BLACK TRACK paint pot but decided to try this on the insistence of the sales clerk and I find that it gives you that perfect precision line and the product last quite awhile and is long wearing. But the price is a little high

Expensive but worth it! It never comes off without makeup remover.
I will buy this until I save up for permanent makeup. Until then, this is the next best thing.

I love, love, love this eyeliner. I have been around the block; testing all forms of waterproof, long lasting eye liners and this one came out on top. I touch my eyes quite a bit but this eyeliner will not come off. It is easy to apply and dries quickly, bonding to the skin.

The only downside to this liner is that it only comes in black. Take note MAC!

I have used many different brands of liquid eyeliner in the past, however, this is by far the best product! I apply the liner once in the morning, and I never have to reapply the rest of the day. I even workout and sweat, and the liner stays on. I would highly recommend this product! Just be cautious when applying, because once it dries (which is pretty quick) it is hard to correct!

This eyeliner has been part of my must-haves since I laid my hands on it 10 years ago. I have oily eyelids and monolids. A combination of those two basically means that most eye makeup, waterproof or not, will end up smudging one way or another unless I apply a primer as base. This is the ONLY eyeliner that stays on my eyes without smudging and without having to use a primer. It's perfect especially on days where I'm running late. I've tried many pencil, gel and liquid eyeliners to hopefully find a cheaper alternative to the MAC's liquidlast eyeliner but none match up to the staying power and pigmentation of MAC's. This eyeliner is also truly waterproof, perfect for swimming and rainy days. Only an oil based makeup remover will work. The only cons I have to say about this eyeliner is that it tends to flake a bit near the end of the day or if you apply multiple coats of it. The eyeliner also gets more clumpy faster than other liquid liners (though this has never stopped me from still using it... ). Despite these cons, no other eyeliner (including the other MAC liquid liners) has come close to MAC's Liquidlast for staying power.

This eyeliner is amazing. It goes on smoothly and the wand makes it easy to apply thin or thick. It lasts all day, doesn't budge even on the hottest of days earn makeup tends to smudge. The only downfall is that I even have trouble getting it off with makeup remover. It could be my makeup, but I've never had that issue before. Nonetheless, great product that's worth the price.