This Eye liner is very nice in that it stays on all day. I have a problem with finding eye liner that doesn't sweat off and smear, which budge proof accomplishes. I love the color ( I bought Cinnabar) and it goes well with my red hair. My only issue with this makeup is that it does smudge a bit after a few hours. While it doesn't come off it gets a bit blurry looking. Still it stays better than a lot of the other products I have tried. the tip of the pencil also gets dull really fast, and it never really is a point because it's a twist pencil not a sharpen-able one.