Got the Maybelline Colossal Masacra and let me just say I was skeptical of all the claims being made (i.e. "9x bigger"). But I gave it a go.

First, WOW... the brush handle was easy to hold onto and actual bristles are very compact taking in the perfect amount of mascara (no need to pump).
As I applied it, I noticed an instant difference with my lashes. Mind you I already have really long ones where ppl think they're fake (previously using L'Oreal's Voluminous), but this sure made them even super long with a bit of help from an eye lash curler (unfortunately this does not give the added curl affect). I won't say this masacra makes lashes 9x longer/thicker, perhaps 5-6X. I usually apply 2-3 coats for a dramatic look, but I only needed one coat for this mascara. The texture is smooth. The collagen in this product definitely makes eyelashes look very natural and plump them up right away.

However, I get overly excited when mascaras claim no clumping, but sure enough there were some tiny ones which had to be combed through. Also, this product is limited in shades and should come in waterproof.

Overall, if you want dramatic lashes with the help of a curler... this is your DREAM mascara!!!

Enjoy!

I don't have very long lashes, so I always try to use a mascara that lengthens. Although this didn't, I found that it really fills and thickens my lashes. So, I use my Maybelline New York Define-a lash (the lime green bottle) first - to lengthen and then use the Colossal to thicken. It works really well. The only thing is I am sensitive to smells and can't believe how terrible this is! It is very strong at first and I thought it would go away, but I can smell it until I wash it off before bed. I won't use it often, but definitely when I'm going out on the town and want to look fantabulous :)

I really liked this. And I am picky when it comes to mascara. It doesn't clump as much as other products, and I could probably get away with 1 coat, but am still applying 2 out of habit. My lashes are long, but this makes them pop! I like that it comes off easily as well. It smudges a bit after alot of wear, but this is definitely a product I will be buying in the future...

so much volume

I got this product and I love it. It doesn't smudge as much as some other products that I have tried, which is important for me because my lashes are long and straight, and with mascara on rub against my glasses/upper eyelids quite a bit.
It doesn't clump, and I found that I only needed about one coat -- sometimes I go with two, depending on the mascara.
Definitely worth trying!

I received this mascara as a member of the Product Review Club. I was excited to try out a new mascara. I wear glasses and like to add a bit of pop to my eyes with mascara either by volume or colour. The following is how I would sum up my impression of the mascara:

Pro:
-the mascara did not clump on the brush
-loved the size of the brush
-the mascara was not difficult to remove at the end of the day

Con:
-I suffer with sinus problems and anything that has a strong smell bothers me. Considering that it was so close to my nose, I could smell it hours after application.
-I have long lashes with a natural curl. I like mascara's that add volume, but this just did not do it for me. The claim of 9X the volume in just one coat is false.

Overall I did like the mascara, despite the fact that it did not have the same volumizing effect as other mascara's. However, the company will have to do something about the smell for me to use it again.

A great mascara, especially compared to some of the older varieties maybelline has put out. It goes on smooth, doesn't clump and provides a reasonable amount of volume for a mascara of this quality. It does have a bit of an odd smell, but it really doesn't bother me.

An all-round great mascara, not clumpy and not too heavy. I love the big fat brush. It has finer bristles that seperate the lashes nicely and it gives more volume than my regular brand. Lovely packaging, too - the yellow and purple are very eye catching- someone aced their colour theory!

I was thrilled to receive this mascara since it claims to provide 9x volume from the first application. I am not one of those lucky women who have long, lush lashes. I have sparse, short and fine lashes, and usually the only way for my eyelashes to frame my eyes is if I use false lashes. Since receiving it, I have used Maybelline Colossal Volum' Express Mascara several times in order to provide my review on it.

The first time, I applied the mascara only to one set of eyelashes, leaving the other set bare. When compared with my natural lashes, the mascara made a noticeable difference. My lashes were darker in tint than usual; however, I didn't find that it made them more lush, longer or thicker. I have used other mascaras that had better impact with less work, as I had to apply 2 to 3 coats to see any difference.

As others have indicated, the smell seems strange for a mascara. Perhaps they can create a scent-free formulation of it.

I'd also like a waterproof version, as I found that my mascara felt as though it was melting off mid-way through the day and left slight smudge-marks under my eyes.

Overall, Maybelline Colossal Volum'Express Mascara does a good job for a drugstore mascara. I would probably buy it again if a waterproof formula was available.

I was looking forward to trying a mascara that works well on my short lashes, so after receiving this product I applied 2 coats on one eye, left the other natural, and went to work. My co-workers noticed the difference-only when I pointed it out. Based on my experience with other mascaras of similar cost, this one did create a better volumizing effect without the usual clumping--something that we all look for, don't we? Although I don't think it lengthenened them. Besides the smell, if you're looking for a mascara that creates volume, doesn't clump, and doesn't cost a fortune, then this product is for you.