Amazing amazing amazing! I've been using it for years, and that's all I can say about it.

The first thing I noticed about this mascara is the smell, it is the main reason I do not use it. I have very long lashes and this mascara makes them look very fake- not a look I like. I will not buy this product again as I was not pleased with it.

I love this mascara, it is the best one I have used! It does not clump, dries quickly, and makes my eyelashes thick and long - not fake and cheap looking like some mascaras do. It lasts all day, and it is easy to remove. I have never had a problem with it running, and it smells like lilacs to me. I would highly suggest this product!

It's smudge and waterproof and make your lashes look natural

This mascara is great! It gives me the volume and length that i need! Its super great and reliable.
The only downside is after you've used it for a while, it gets a little clumpy, but that just means it's time for a new one!

Great mascara, it has a good brush which allows for volume and thickness. However I did find that it had a funny smell. It would take me off guard first thing in the morning. I am not sure if it is all of them or if I had a bad one but the product itself still worked great.

Best Mascara, my top favourite it makes my lashes full and very long. People think my lashes are fake when i wear this mascara! I use an eyelash curler before using the mascara and then use about 2-3 coats for them to look their best!

This bad boy is the love of my life! This is the mascara I always come back to! Some hate it, some like it, I LOVE IT! It gives me so much volume and length ! ( what else do I need to add ? ) It's cheap, it's available EVERYWHERE and its PUURFECT ! :) It can make your lashes a little clumpy, but personally, I like clumps ( controllable ones :p !! ) because they give you the volume you want :) Whenever I wear this mascara, people always compliment me and say : Oh, are you wearing falsies ? And I'm like pshh no honey ! ONLY mascara! :) and they ask : which one is it ? I reply : the yellow one from Maybelline ^^ ... Oh by the way, I haven't tried the waterproof version one, soo I can't speak for that one, but the regular version is PURO AMOR !

I bought this because of the commercials on TV but I won't buy it again. Maybe I'll try Cover Girl. I had a favourite from Avon but they aren't making it anymore. This wasn't supposed to clump but it did. Did not like this and sure don't know why it's rated #2.

I actually borrowed this mascara from my girlfriend on a trip (I know, tsk tsk) but I was literally scraping the remnants from my YSL tube. It worked well for me so I decided to buy it the next time I was at the drugstore since frankly I'm tired of shelling out $30 a pop for my fav YSL mascara. I like it, it definitely lengthens and defines which is what I like but the only complaint would be that I have to apply at least to 2-3 coats to thicken due to it's thin consistency. All in all for the price great product!!