I've heard many many good reviews on this, so I bought this and tried it out. I didn't like it, it did not give me a smooth line on my lid, nor did it last long. I got raccoon eyes within an hour of having this on! I also didnt like sharpening it, I get lazy. It's great for someone who just tightlines, but I wont use this for a winged look. It doesnt give me that flattering smooth line that gel or liquid gives.