I think this is a good basic eye pencil. I like that it can be removed and cleaned up with a q-tip. The color payoff is quite good, but it not super pigmented. There are quite a few colors to choose from as well. This doesn't last a very long time, however.

love this eyeliner! There are 5 shades, black, dark brown, light brown/bronze, purple, and blue.
It glides on your eyes very smoothly without tugging, and it won't smudge throughout the day. It has really great lasting power, and it's only $3! great product, totally worth trying!

For the price of this eyeliner, you really can't go wrong! It's long lasting and does not smudge all that easily. It takes a bit more effort to apply the eyeliner so that it is actually visible but, all in all, a good product.