It obviously varies shade to shade, but there are some really great shades available. A few I've tried have incredible pigmentation and lasts for such a long time without creasing.

If you have oily lids, about the only one that will work is Milk. All of the others I've tried crease like crazy. That's with using a good primer, blending, and setting with shadow. I really want to love the other shades I have, but they're too "greasy" for me to use.

Great colour selection, great formula, smooth and easy to apply. But bad for those with sensitive eyes!
That's why I say stay away!

Nice rich colour, with excellent staying power.

These eye pencils are quite lovely. They glide on and are very pigmented, and they last all day.

I found my NYX Jumbo eye pencil in colour Milk in my post box today and I was so glad to finally try it because I've heard only good words about it. So, to begin with, I ordered it from Ebay about a week ago and I found it pretty pricey for an eye pencil (it costs 5£ !) but it turns out that it was totally worth it. The colour is very bright and creamy, it applies very smoothly and barely creases, so it works perfectly as an eye shadow primer. The only thing I disliked was the packaging, it is very difficult to sharpen, because the base is not wooden, but plastic. :C But I'm about to depot it anyway, so it's alright, that way I get to save a lot of product. Overall NYX Jumbo Pencil in Milk is definitely worth to not only lay your eyes on, but also to lay it on your eyes.

I love my nxy pencil. I have it in milk and i use it a lot as an inner corner highlight. The formula is great, and they apply really easily for someone like me who doesn't have a lot of experience with makeup.

I like these Jumbo pencil, they are pretty cheap and have lots of colors to choose from. I don't use eyeliners often, but I do like these NYX ones.

They are a bit hard to find in Canada, where I live, so I buy them in US often. I like that they are thick and creamy and can be used for an eyeshadow also.

I don't care for this product at all. This is my number one pet peeve about eye pencils, they need to be sharpened.Sharpening them tends to waste product ,I even read about a reviewer who was putting them in the freezer before sharpening so she wouldn't loose as much. That is just way to much work for me, you need a sharpener just the right size, and loosing product is not cool with me. Money is hard enough to come by, let alone paying for a product that you loose so much product. This one is definitely not for me, I can't stand any products that I have to waste time, energy and fighting with the thing to get it sharp. Sorry NYX, you do have man other great products.

Having a very fair complexion can be difficult to find good eye makeup. After discovering this eye pencil, there was no going back to eye shadows! With just one line on your eye lids, it looks like you spent time applying it with pencil.
Best part? Does NOT rub off, crease, just stays in place!