Ugh! I normally love NYX products, especially those bright coloured eyeliners and contour palettes. But this liner just DID. NOT. WORK! It always smudges no matter how much primer and setting spray I put on before and after! I've had better luck with other brands like Revlon and Sephora.

Although this liner has great staying power, it's definitely made for the more advanced liquid liner user. Very thin paintbrush-like applicator can get quite messy if you don't have a super steady hand. I'm able to get a good cat eye but it usually takes some q-tips & eye makeup remover to get things even and less messy looking.