This is why NYX has catapulted into the mainstream as one of the best inexpensive substitutes to MAC out there. The black and highlight matte eye shadows are highly pigmented, long wearing (especially with primer), and have no fall out. They look natural and can be buildable. The price is great - and offers plenty of product. Worth the hype.

this review is about nyx eyeshadow's in general, not just a specific shade. but for those who are wondering, here are the colors i have:
- Charcoal Brown
- Black
- Brown
- Dark Brown
- Palette in Mysterious Brown Eyes

these shadows are awesome! they're richly pigmented and easy to work with. one of the best eyeshadows i've ever tried, i like these even better than MAC. plus you can't beat the price.
here's a swatch of charcoal brown (with no base):
http://tinypic.com/view.php?pic=4tsdpy&s=5