really good

this eyeliner is sooo good. It makes it very easy to apply and the liner itself is very long lasting. It's not matte it has more of a glossy finish but the result is very pretty. I would recommend!

I would buy this again!

I think the cost of this liner is reasonable. I would say for a khol liner it is the best "waterproof" liner that I've used. It does smudge a little bit, but I've tried so many different brands, and this has the least amount of smudging. I can no longer use a liquid or pottes gel liner, as both seem to give me a chemical burn type reaction on my lids. So this has proven to be my best bet.

I ran out of my Urban Decay 24/7 eyeliner and didn't want to spend a lot of money on another one, so I bought this NYX one and I like it a lot! It's comparable to the UD ones, although I don't think it is as creamy. I really like the pigmentation and the lasting power.