Not a hit.

I got a big bag of these for my oldest dogs birthday. Fortunately he will eat just about anything and he sort of likes them, he has to look at them awhile but he eats them. My other dog won't touch them. I wouldn't get them again. There are a lot of other treats that both dogs will eat. These have a really intense smell, as soon as the bag is opened the smell of rosemary hits you in the nose. They aren't strips, they are more of a chunk, sort of semi hard.