This is and will always be my favourite black pencil eyeliner. It applies beautifully, and the colour is just the right black. I am trying to go cruelty free though, and unfortunately Rimmel still tests on animals. It's unfortunate, because I love this product so much, and the price is so great! Definitely would still recommend it though, and I will still use the eyeliner pencil I have as long as I possibly can (and hopefully someday Rimmel goes cruelty-free so I can get more of this eyeliner!).

Smooth gliding pencil works great for lining your water line, and matches up great with my top liquid liner, ten out of ten for sure!! Oh and the price is the cherry on top :)

Creamy. Easy to apply and very good quality for the price. Definitely something to try if you have not yet done so.

love this liner!
great price for the quality of the product. I wear contact lenses and this liner does not bother me at all.

I love this eyeliner it applies easy and it's a smooth creamy feeling not dry and sticky

This is my favourite black pencil liner I've tried! It's easy to smoke out if you want the smoky look, and it stays all day without smudging.

I love this brand of eyeliner! It goes on smooth and lasts and doesn't bother my eyes

Awesome eyeliner for the waterline. Long lasting and won't smudge. Great price and comes in a variety of colors as well as in waterproof. If your looking for an affordable eyeliner that will stay put then this is the one for you!

This eye liner pencil is very pigmented. Its glides on perfectly on the water line and the skin as well! It is a must in your make up collection.

This nude is from the waterproof kohl kajal line. It has a very creamy consistency which makes it my go to for lining my waterline as white is too harsh looking.