I suffer from very dry scalp, especially during the winter. Selsun Blue helps keep my flakes in check. I get the "hydra" version and it actually smells nice.

This works great I only use it about twice a week. It doesn't have a great smell but leaves my hair soft and shiny

My mom had a bottle in my cabinet that I used up while I had dandruff from taking accutane.

First off, this stained the area around the drain of my tub blue, a pretty dark blue too. Nizoral stained a bit as well but not as badly as the Selsun.

It did work on my dandruff but not as well as Nizoral. I feel selsun blue was on par with H&S;but H&S;is cheaper.

I would say try it but, the differences in active ingredients might work with you.