Loving the Shiseido Instant Eye and Lip Makeup Remover. It does a fabulous job on both my waterproof liner and mascara, as well as a very clean job on my lips. I use covergirl all day lip stain and it can be really tough to get off - but the Shiseido does it no problem. Comparatively priced to the Clinique Remover that I love so much - and actually you get a little more in the Shiseido Bottle! Worth the purchase price and leaves your skin feeling clean but not oily.