Not a great product

I was really underwhelmed after using this product and am really disappointed. I've heard people rave about this liner for a long time and I was excited to try it. But once I started using it I found it really finicky. It didn't draw a clean line -- it seemed like it was skipping in places. I would try going over it multiple times but it was like it wouldn't draw on my lid. I applied it without any primer or powder, so it's not like the product was reacting or interfering with another. Also, the second time I started using it, the felt(?) part started flaking and crumbling. I don't know if I received a bad/old one, but I wasn't expecting that. One thing I can remark is how black it is. It's jet black and doesn't fade throughout the day. It's also not waterproof. I can easily rub it off my eyes with my finger. Overall, super disappointed because of the hype and the price. There are better, cheaper alternatives or just use a gel liner.

No thank you

I liked this eyeliner for about a week and then it started drying out and isn’t bold enough for me, I wouldn’t buy it again as I found better ones since I bought this one. I’m not impressed with stila products 😪 and it’s way too expensive for the quality

Very disappointing

So many ladies swear by the Stila Liquid Eyeliner pens but I was extremely disappointed even returning the first one as defective to Sephora and getting a replacement. The applicator tip never got saturated enough for a crisp line, causing it to look patchy and uneven pigmentation. I am a regular liquid eye liner wearing for years and this one really failed to impress me. The felt tip was always dry and the pen seemed to run dry in under a month. I won't be buying Stila liquid eyeliner pens again.

The eyeliner did not work for me.. after a few hours it was all gone. I had to redo my eyeliner look.. I don't have greasy lid so I don't know why the eyeliner felt off my eyes

I forgot my eyeliner at home this weekend and had to borrow this off a friend. I had to glide it back and forth several times to see anything come out. It also feels like literally putting a marker to my face. Not a big fan, would rather use a liquid liner than a marker type.