An okay product

If you are looking for a black dark eyeliner to tightly line your waterline i mean sure this will get the job done but it does transfer through the day and won’t stay put too long

Good Product

Great for the price, large eye liner. I just cannot use it on my lower eye or else is smears not long after using it. Great for the upper eye lid. And excellent if you need something cheaper. The price is amazing for this.