My to go eye pencil for many years

I’ve been using this waterproof eye pencil for many many years and I will keep purchasing it as long as Yves Saint Laurent produces it. This pencil is very soft and easy to apply and most of all, it lasts all day without making mess around my eyes. It costs around $45 but they are all worth it as I need to purchase it maximum twice a year (and I use it almost every day!!). Definitely recommend it! Hopefully they will never discontinue this item!