We would like to send you notifications on the latest Product Review Club offers.

Eye Shadow - Prestige Reviews

Sort by:  DateRating
1-20 of 98

MAC Cosmetics Eyeshadow

493 reviews

I really enjoy MAC I always love the colours that they have. I am always adding it to my collection of makeup products,. the eyeshadow always stays in place I always get compliments from people who want to know what I use. This is a really good staple to have in anyone’s...
Benefit Cosmetics Creaseless Cream Eyeshadow/Liner

18 reviews

This is a great shimmery taupe color, no glitter, but has a nice everyday shine. Only problem is that it doesn't last all day. By the end of the work day, there's still color on the lids, but the shine is gone and it's kinda blah! So is it creaseproof, sure, but that's about it.
Make Up For Ever Star Powder

15 reviews

It's an amazing powder! Very effective, easy to apply, lasts long time and doesn't roll. It's sparkly and glamorous! Worth the money and will last long time! Highly recommend!
Bobbi Brown Long Wear Cream Shadow

5 reviews

This is a super pretty, easy to apply cream shadow stick. I have the shade "Golden Pink", and it looks subtle but lovely on the eye, although maybe a bit more sparkly/glittery looking than the Stila shimmer and glow shadows. It lasts FOREVER, I can get 14+ hours from it without...
bareMinerals Eyeshadow

15 reviews

I have the metallic gold eye shadow. You can put it on as powder which looks good BUT if mixed with water it becomes a metallic paste which goes on evenly and smooth. It is awesome
Benefit Cosmetics Velvet Eyeshadow

3 reviews

ChickAdvisor sent me this amazing eyeshadow as a prize for winning one of their contests and I am absolutely in love with it! It truly has a velvety texture and glides on smooth. It is easy to blend, which makes it versatile for a variety of different looks. It is a very easy...
Benefit Cosmetics Big Beautiful Eyes

4 reviews

Personally, I love this product. It is everything I need and more. I typically chose nudes over bright colors so it works for me. The makeup itself is long lasting. I use the concealer under my eyes because I have dark spots. It covers them up really well. The shade is exactly...
Make Up For Ever Eyeshadow

8 reviews

I buys this product for me and my daughter we love it. We go though a lot of it. It super easy to put on, as well to wipe off. My daughter is sensitive to a lot of eyeshadows but the product works for us.
Make Up For Ever Aqua Cream

15 reviews

I love this I use this makeup when I go to parties I am so amazed on how this is made cause it is so perfect for my skin and I matches my outfit and I look amazing wearing it
Buxom Stay-There Eye Shadow

3 reviews

Another stay put, awesome pigmented eye shadow! Buildable - subtle or bold. Customisable when blended with their other colours but can become goopy if worked with too long. I do wish there were more colours offered. However; great company! Looking forward to more!!
bareMinerals Ready Eyeshadow 4.0

2 reviews

I have the smaller pallette with the two shadows in it but i love it! I have the plum purple with a pale pink combo! Creates a subtle but beautiful smokey eye. It goes on nicely and lasts all day. I was never much of a fan of Bare Minerals because I find them pricey- But I'm...
KVD Vegan Beauty Spellbinding Book of Shadows

3 reviews

This is my favourite palette I have ever purchased. The colours are vibrant and fun. The variety allows for many different looks for day and night. Definitely worth the price tag.
Buxom Waterproof Smoky Eye Sticks

1 review

The most amazing eye liner I have ever received. I will buy again and again. Goes on smooth and stays on for the whole day. Good colour, goes on solid.
Make Up For Ever Artist Shadow

10 reviews

I got a deluxe sample of this with my 500 point perk from Sephora. I have the shade I544, which is a shimmery, satin taupe. I find that the pigmentation is decent with this particular shade, though it does take a bit to build it up. It is a bit gritty in texture, and kicks...
Make Up For Ever Aqua Matic Waterproof Eyeshadow

3 reviews

If you're looking for a waterproof cream eyeshadow that is truly waterproof & will last throughout the day, this eyeshadow is for you. I have very watery eyes due to allergies & I find that typically powder eye shadows can't hold up during the day. With these aqua matic eye...
bareMinerals 5-in-1 BB Advanced Performance Cream Eyeshadow Broad Spectrum SPF 15

6 reviews

This cream eyeshadow is heaven for busy moms who don’t have a lot of time to get ready. The creamy feel of the eyeshadow is smooth and easy to apply. It lasts all day!
Bobbi Brown Sand Eye Palette

1 review

Absolutely gorgeous palette! Amazing colour payoff. Pretty neutrals with glitter/shimmer.
Charlotte Tilbury Colour Chameleon Eyeshadow Pencil

6 reviews

I have a number of these and I use them almost daily. They are very long lasting (thing waterproof) and just the most gorgeous colours. My favourite is Amber Haze and Champagne Diamonds. Perfect for blue eyes. I know they recommend the sticks for specific eye colours but really...
Laura Mercier Caviar Stick Eye Colour

12 reviews

My favourite smokey eye base. It's true black colour, no shimmer. Because this is cream to powder and it sets quicker and better than other products in this category, I recommend carefully applying in layers and blending well with a due fibre style brush (Laura Mercier used to...
bareMinerals High Shine Eye Color

1 review

Bought this at a sale in Sephora and I love it! I actually bought two colours; Meteorite and Glisten. I find the applicator really inconvenient and really just wastes a whole lot of shadow. But the shadow itself is very nice; the colours are bright and are very pigmented if you...