We would like to send you notifications on the latest Product Review Club offers.

Eyeliner Reviews

Sort by:  DateRating
1-20 of 902

MAC Cosmetics Fluidline

242 reviews

Fluidline from MAC is the original potted gel eyeliner you can use with a brush for freehand strokes. This is just excellent for the cat-flick / feline flick if used with a fine brush you can create all sorts of eye make-up detail and it comes in different shades. This pot...
Bare Minerals Eyeliner/Shadow

7 reviews

Texture and product is easy to use. Although sometimes because it is so soft it breaks off and smudges. This is true black color with a bit of sheen.
Palladio Liquid Eyeliner

6 reviews

Goes on super easy, and stays for a long time! Looks amazing as well. Will definitely buy this product again, and recommend to all my friends and family!
Annabelle Cosmetics Kohl Eyeliner

98 reviews

These are affordable and high quality eye liners! They do live up to more high end liners, but at a fraction of the cost! I love the variety of colors as well!
Rimmel London Soft Kohl Kajal Eyeliner

70 reviews

I don't think this is too bad of an eyeliner. It doesn't really smudge which I like and stays on for the most part. I like how dark the black is, as well..
L'Oreal Lineur Intense Brush Tip Liquid Liner

30 reviews

The only eyeliner I use! I love the brush tip for this product. It gives me a cleaner, smoother and sharper look using the brush tip versus a pencil or felt tip. It is long lasting makeup which needs very little touch up throughout the day. I get compliments on how nice my...
Kiss Me Eyeliner

8 reviews

i love using this to do mt cat eyeliner, it makes my wings so sharp and precise. i recommend this to anyone who loves the pin up/vintage look, definitely makes your eyes pop.
Almay Intense i-Color Bring Out Eyeliner

13 reviews

I have difficult eyes this eye liner works perfect for me!! it comes with a tiny sharpener on the end of the pencil to keep it sharp and also winds up the stick s you go through it! my favourite eye liner
Revlon ColorStay Liquid Liner

17 reviews

One of the best liquid liners I’ve used in a long time! I love how black it is! It dries down really nicely and I love that it lasts pretty long as well!
Revlon Bedroom Eyes Powder Liner

8 reviews

I wanted to like this so bad!applies so messy though,powder kept getting under my eyes...love the color though,just not for me!maybe if applied a different way
Almay Liquid Liner

27 reviews

A pretty good eyeliner overall. I have this in black, and it goes on smoothly and is quite easy to apply (but not idiot proof - practice first!)...my only qualm with this product is the fact that it doesn't last long, so it smudges - I had a waterproof liquid eyeliner before...
COVERGIRL Line Exact Liquid Liner

25 reviews

This is by far the best eyeliner I've had in long time. Covers my eyelids perfect last all day long. I have had no smuging. I'm most happy to say trying it i for sure be buying again I recommend to anyone
MAC Cosmetics Liquidlast Eyeliner

34 reviews

This is the best liquid liner for my menopausal skin. Easy to use, stays all day, no transferring to my upper eye lids. This is the best. Really recommended. Forget waterproof this is oily skin proofs perfecto!!
Maybelline New York Define-a-Line Eyeliner

39 reviews

I love this eyeliner. Specifically for my waterline. It doesn’t budge and lasts all day! I also use it if I want a Smokey eye or smoked out eyeliner look as it tends to blend really well
Lise Watier Glitter Eyeliner Pencils

11 reviews

I love how it glides like butter on senstive eye area. Does not tug or pull and also stays all day long without smudging. I am contacts wearer and it does not irrite my eyes, either.
Physicians Formula Eye Definer Automatic Eye Pencil

10 reviews

Wear this eye pencil every day on my water line! Can make it faint or extremely black! Glides on like butter! Sometime hard to get a new one started but use on back of hand and after that no problems!
L'Oreal HIP High Intensity Pigments Color Truth Cream Eyeliner

24 reviews

I really like the packaging, it is so cute. But for the balm itself, it's nothing special. Smells great like sweet lemon. It started out kinda hard and grainy, but got soft once I got past the top layer. an EOS balm costs €6 where I live, so it is really expensive for a balm...
Hot Topic Black Lip And Eye Pencil

3 reviews

I purchased this on a recommendation from a friend and it costs $2. I love that it goes on smoothly, almost but not quite as nice as the Urban Decay glide on pencils. One con is that it can transfer because it's so smooth and it doesn't have the best staying power on the...
GOSH Cosmetics Velvet Touch Eyeliner

12 reviews

very nice eye liner that applies smoothly because it is creamy and has a nice colour to it ( mine is black) but it does irritate my eyes ( they turn red very quickly) so i had to switch to a different brand and also even tho it says waterproof it isn't , I had to apply a few...
L'Oréal Paris Telescopic Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner

9 reviews

I love this eyeliner! Maybe it is not the best, but I'm satisfy with it. It stays the whole day without smudging. If you did a mistake, just wait a few sec to let it dry and scratch it off with ur nail. It is tricky to remove it, u need a good oil based make-up remover.