Ok, if you dog can stand the taste.

Right out of the package my children smelled these and said they smelled like goldfish crackers. They definitely have a potent smell! Well 2 out of 3 of my chihuahuas ate it. I was so excited for this product to come for my 11 year old chihuahua with hip problems. She however would not eat it. She smelled it and laid down beside it and went to sleep, that is the reason for the 3 stars. My 11 week old puppy had no problems eating it, neither did my 3 yr old chihuahua. I was disappointed though because the dog I actually got it for didn't like it.