Was great at first

I thought this was my best eyeliner purchase as of yet until recently. Whenever I use it I feel as if it’s more dry and clumps up sometimes and ruins my wing and then I’m stuck having to make a bigger one then I have to try to fix the other one to make them the same then in the end I eventually feel like a raccoon. Oh and it’s always living a print on my upper eyelid which is super annoying for my hooded eyes.