I use this as my base color

I use this as my base color. It’s super cheap and super versatile. There’s quite a few colors to choose from and the come in satin, metallic and chrome.

For colours, in particular that you wear on the brow bone, I find Annabelle offers a few great, not too shiny options. I have purchased Aura quite a few times. The colour range doesn't change too much, but the quality is pretty amazing for a product under $8.