My Friend gave me this as a gift......I love Benefit , the packaging is super cool and the products are great!!! Does not go on too thick , thinner than it appears and it glids on ....!!!!

The pencil is ok. I am trying to get used to the thickness of it. But it is easy to grab as it is thick. It smudges a little bit, to create a smoky, smolderin eye effect.. It doesn't stay on the water line though. It makes great punky looks, but other than that it is not the best.