This mascara seemed promising at first, tried using it as a second coat over my existing favourite to add extra volume and I liked the results at first, the brush was nice and it went on easily however this mascara smudged horribly. I even tried only wearing it on my top lashes to see if that would have better results and it still did not last through out the day. Will stick to my drug store mascara from now on, not worth the cost.

I wanted to love this mascara, but the best I can do is feel mehhh about it. First, the smell irritates my eyes, almost like the chemicals are offing toxic vapors. Second, it dries very brittle and stiff. Third, it sticks my lashes together so it appears that I have four lashes instead of however many I actually have. Fifth, it's difficult to remove. Sixth, it's pricey. I expect more from something I'm paying that much for, and the quality just isn't there. I know it's well reviewed and highly touted by celebrities, etc...but I just don't like it, period. Fortunately the one I have came from a sample box so I didn't have to pay $20 just to find out I hate it. Sorry BeneFit - I usually love you!

Not my favorite mascara. Burned my eyes and did not help my lashes look full and separate.

I love most of Benefit's other products, so I very disappointed when I bought this mascara. For the price, it just isn't worth it. The results are underwhelming and you can buy a drugstore brand mascara that is more effective for a small fraction of the price. I recommend Benefit's other mascara - They're Real! It is far superior.

I used this product after all of the hype from a few of my friends and I have to say, I was extremely disappointed. For the cost of the product I would have thought the results would have been far more outstanding. While it did not clump as promised, it definitely did not make my lashes stand out any more than a cheaper product. It did not add shine or length. I would not fall into the hype and purchase again.

I love how this mascara looks when I first put it on, but within an hour it smears/runs under my eyes. I end up just looking like I have really dark under eye circles.

The consistency of this product changed within a month from good coverage to becoming dry and hard to apply. Not a fan...

Great packaging, cute idea but the badgal brush is just too big, not effective really, and messy. Also dries up quickly. Too expensive for the quality

i bought a smaller size and i did not find this worth my money. I had to coat my lashes a good 2-3 times and then add something else on top, it didnt feel like mascara. I did notice however when i had to take it off it washed away with no problem.

I had high hopes for this mascara, as I had heard a lot of good things about it and have enjoyed other Benefit brand products. Boy, was I wrong! There is not one thing that I liked about this mascara. The brush was too large, so it was very difficult to apply without getting it everywhere. It took me about 5 coats to get an 'acceptable' look - better than no mascara at all, but still not great. It really didn't add any length or volume, so it basically made my already dark lashes a bit darker. To make matters worse, it flaked and was all over my undereye area within 2 hours. I've tried it multiple times, even tried wiping the brush before use and using it with a primer, but the results were the same each time. I'm extremely disappointed! I would definitely not buy this again (it was expensive, too!) and I would not recommend it to anyone.