I have tried too many mascara so to list, this is my holy grail! No matter how many mascaras I try, I always go back to the roller lash.

I LOVE this mascara! It separates my lashes and makes them look super long. It also doesn't smudge. I just wish it was cheaper!

I'm obsessed with this mascara. I have very long, but sparse eyelashes that are hard to curl. This mascara does it for me AND makes me lashes look super full.

My favorite mascara I have ever tried. But also beware about clumping if you don't apply it correctly.

*Sigh* in my search for the perfect mascara (does it even exist?) I decided to give Benefit Roller Lash a try.I LOVE Benefit's Their real mascara and was hoping the quality of Roller lash would live up to the Benefit name.
For me it was a huge pass.
I followed exact instructions on how to use this mascara,even watching a few Youtube videos to make sure I was getting the best application.

Try after try continued to disappoint me in both performance and formula.
The packaging is so cute, but sadly I feel like that is the only good thing about this products.

The products consistency is tar-like, sticky and never really dries. is you have long lashes be ready for a mess.

Also its performance was not good at all from my experience, I would try to build of volume by zig-zagging the mascara from the root of my lashes to the tip and it was having a hard time finding its way to the tips of my lashes so my lashes look much shorter and usual.

I will stick to other mascara's in my makeup bag

This stuff is so much better than that 3-D product that is out there - much less expensive and goes on so much easier! I think it looks just as good as the 3D and gives me great lashes.

I found this product to be average. Not one I would rush out for,

I am a HUGE fan of both Benefit's Bad Gal Lash and They're Real mascaras, but am not so into Roller Lash.
Roller Lash has a "Hook n Roll" design on the brush, meant to catch and lift your lashes and give them a decent curl. The wand is curved, and has shorter bristles on the inner edge, with longer ones on the outer edge. This always messes with me for some reason (any curved wand from any mascara), because I find it hard to use the same technique on both eyes with this brush, and then my lashes might look thicker on one side, more curled on the other, etc.
I also find the plastic/rubber bristles to be a little rough on my eyes sometimes - maybe its me but I always get poked a little bit when I'm trying to apply the mascara to the very base of my lashes.
I do think the curved brush can emphasize and help lift the lashes, but it isn't a noticeable difference compared to my other mascaras.
The formula of Roller Lash seems a bit different than Benefit's other mascaras. For whatever reason, I find this to really clump my lashes together if I'm not careful. It also seems to flake off and become smudged throughout the day, a little more than I'm used to. My eyes are hooded and eye makeup tends to transfer on me, to my brow bone and under eye, but more so with certain mascaras and this is one of them.
Overall I would definitely recommend Roller Lash if you're interested in trying it and don't mind the price. I'm glad I tried it because I love Benefit's other mascaras, and I love mascara in general so I had to see what the product was like for myself. Unfortunately, for me this product is a little too clumpy and smudgy, and the brush design isn't my favourite, so it isn't worth the price.

I don't know what's wrong but this product didn't work for me. I know this is a holy grail to everyone but not for me. I've tried so many mascaras and although I love the brush of this one but the formula is very thick and doesn't seem to dry. I literally went all day feeling my eyelashes to see if they had dried, and sure enough they hadn't!

I've tried many mascaras but this one is my absolute favourite. Don't even need to curl my lashes and they stay curled up and perfect all day long. Id give it more stars if I could. Not a fan of the price but I will pay for this product again. nothing compares.