A bit of a flop for me i'm afraid. Wen't on nice a smooth but smudged instantly, ran, and was not flattering at all. The price was great, but that's the only nice thing I have to say about this eye liner.

It's a average eyeliner. Not the greatest but not the worst. Fantastic price though!

I rarely rarely rarely wear eyeliner so I actually really like this kind because it's cheap but it works. I only buy this eyeliner in Toffee - like a gold colour. It's perfect for day use because it's so subtle due to the smudging effect and also the colour. There's like 100 colours in this so I'm sure anyone could find one that works great for a very natural no make-up look. If I want more drama, I don't use this product. It's definitely a cheap eyeliner. But I like it and I'll keep buying!

My friends and I used to buy this constantly back in high school! It was pretty much always in our bags and we thought it was pretty awesome stuff. It's a good product for a good price with lots of colours to choose from.
Now that I've experimented alot more with different products and brands, I would still buy this eye liner even though there are better ones out there. This does tend to smudge and comes off very easily. (But that's also a plus when you're new to eye makeup!)
I've tried a few of the different shades but mostly stuck with the Black Shimmer. It's a decent black liner with some tiny shimmers that makes it great for going out/special occasions!
Overall I don't buy this often anymore, but definitely recommend it. It's cheap and does a good job!

Eh, I cant say Im a fan. Its definitely very cheap, but it smudges and does not go on smoothly. It is also not waterproof...will not recommend.

I was just trying to find a really GOOD cheap eyeliner that didn't flake into my eye. It's a really amazing product for the price, and they have many colors ( I went with Very Black ) and it is also an great idea for contact wearers because it doesn't flake AND it's sooo easy to get off with some makeup remover so your eyes don't get irritated.