Literally bombproof

This is easily the best and most bomb proof mascara I have ever used, and I flat out refuse to use any other mascara now that I know this exists on the market. It survived a funeral and left my eyes beautiful and completely un-smudged after hours of heavy crying. It has also survived a hot yoga class, and swimming with the same results. Removal with eye makeup remover is easy, and this product definitely meets my sensitive skin needs!
Would highly recommend.

It flakes

I have used this mascara several times. I like the wand and I like how it's waterproof. I do not like how it starts to flake off and fall on my face through out the day.

Love this!!!

I’ve been trying for years to buy a Mascara which lengthens my lashes, doesn’t flake and can be removed with just water. This does all three. It may be a bit expensive but is totally worth it!

Not the best, not the worst

This mascara is solidly ok to me - and for $25, I expect better.

Background: Very active, very long/thick lashes (Latisse!), live in a super dry climate (usually struggle with flaky mascara over smudging)

Previous go-to mascara has been Maybelline Lash Sensational and the Clinique Fit honestly quite comparable (although way different types of brushes). I have to brush out quite a few clumps with Fit and it has come off on to my face during my workouts. I think it's because it comes off best with water (not quite in tubes but it does stay together sort of) and I am a sweaty beast. I also have to wipe off black bits from my eyebrow line throughout the day and have minor flaking on the lower lash line. I will say, it's not irritating to my contact lensed eyes, so that's good..

My New Go-To Mascara

I'm a contact lens wearer, and have sensitive prone skin around the eyes. I have yet to find a mascara that works with contacts, and easy to take off.
I saw this mascara online and thought I would give it a try.
I'm glad that I bought it! So far (I've only started wearing this mascara a month ago) and it has been great. As its Clinique (and therefore, hypoallergenic), it has not irritated my eyes, and it comes off very easily with warm water.
I also work out and it has not smudged on me yet.
So far, its doing what it says it does.
Would buy this again!