Okay

This product was okay. I love elf products however, this one did not impress me that much. I think it was because it was to liquid for my liking. However, for its price it is decent.

Excellent the first two weeks

I’ve purchases several times, how can you say no to a $3 eye liner. But I grew fed up with it. I love ELF, but this eye liner would only work exceptionally well for the first week or two, and then it would start to dry up. Sometimes it would flake while applying, sometimes I’d buy a brand new one and it was already dry up. So I’ve moved on. The cheap price tag is one thing, but to have to repurchase every few weeks - was no more cost effective than buying one for $15 and it lasting 5x longer