poor pigmentation, weak staying power

Im really disappointed with these shadowsticks! I picked up Guilt and it did not apply very pigmented and after a few hours, they didn't wear well... it may have been the result of the how they reacted with my oily lids, but they looked like they had started to melt off my lids but dried. It was not a good look. It just was one big hot mess! I will have to try these shadow sticks with a shadow base and primer and see if they wear better.