I really don't get the hype around these cream shadows, for me, this color was patchy, not opaque and didn't last at all on my lids. It didn't work well as a primer either. So I couldn't use it as a shadow, couldn't use it as a base, it didn't last. Took way to much time and effort to get it evenly onto my lids. This ones lasted longer and was more opaque, than the Barely Branded champagne color, and it actually quite pink in color, it is a little subtle, but at the same time it's very clear that you are wearing baby pink on your eyes.