I expected beautiful smoky looking lashes and in return received clumpy fairly normal looking mascara's lashes.

This is by far the worst mascara ive used. It was extremely flaky, smelled horrible and did nothing for my lashes. Definetly don't waste you money.

I was very disappointed with this Maybelline mascara. The brush was too big and the wand was too small. Because of the size of the brush, the tube opening was so big that the mascara dried up real fast. I will go back to my CoverGirl Professional Brush Mascara for sure.

I didn't like this mascara it was to thick and made my lashes look clumpy

Flakes throughout the day whether you apply 1 coat or 3. I have shorter lashes, so I tend to buy a lot of mascaras to try to find the perfect one. Gives you length but you have to be very careful or it will end up very clumpy. You have to be sure to wipe all the excess product off the wand. It's an okay mascara but I wouldn't every buy it again. Maybelline is a good company, they just messed up on this one.

I got this mascara in hopes to finally find one that doesnt smudge or come off on my eye lides by the afternoon; however; I find this brand does the same as covergirl and just smears on my eyelides. I found that after using it for a week it clumped on the brush as well. For people with sensative eyes I would not recommend this product. Pay a few dollars extra and get a better brand.

Another bad mascara. At the price it was worth trying

I personally didnt like this mascra. Was clumpy and didnt do nothing for my lashes . i wouldnt reccomend this one

Not the best I've tried.. it ran out quickly and smelt funny after about 2 weeks in the bottle.
The brush became really dry.
It's not cheap either, if you love this mascara though, check out WINNERS! They often have it there for "up to 60% less" hahaa seriously though-department and shoppers drug mart sell it for a lot of moola, that I DON'T really have for things like mascara.
I liked that it was a bright yellow bottle, easy to find... but that's ALL I enjoyed.

I have fairly thick long eyelashes but I wanted a more dramatic effect and thought Maybelline's New York Colossal Volume Mascara would do the trick. Unfortunately i felt my eyelashes were more brittle after use. The mascara itself was good for the first two uses, but once i used it the thrid time (same week) it was dry and clumpy. I don't pump my mascara bottle, as this causes air to dry out the formula faster. Needless to say, I chucked it out later that week. I'll stick to what I know: Avon! :)