absolutely hate it!....I saw this on sale at the drugstore and after a coworker told me how well it works for her I had to try it.....its terrible...the consistancy is far too watery, the brush is too big and the product gets all over your eyelids and it made my average sized lashes much thinner did not volumize at all

This mascara was a huge disappointment! I had used Maybelling for many years (way back when they had the little red "spit box" with the brush) ...l not too many of you will remember this one. Anyway, I was not happy with the Colossal Volume mascara. It went on in messy globs and there was no way you could put on a second coat to enhance your lashes. They went stiff and spiky, and I prefer a more natural look. I found it flaked onto my cheeks too ... not a good look!

Not their best product!

Ok so I mean this mascara sort of works, but not that well....but here is why i hate it....IT STINKS!!!....i mean its not an unplesant smell, but its sooo strong that you can smell it for hours after you put it on...I mean are your eyelashs supposed to smell?

This product lengthens lashes BUT does not make them longer or thicker. My lashes looked whimpy and unnoticable, I would NOT buy it again. It certaintly does not live up to its name. I was disappointed because I had read great reviews about this mascara and once I tried it, I was disappointed with it.

this mascara doesn't extend my lashes like i thought it would. I'm not happy with it at all.

I HATE this mascara, it did nothing for me. No volume or length unless I applied alot.

I'm glad I'm not the only one who thinks it smells funny. I thought it was expired, but I guess they all stink. It didnt work very well either. made my lases "skinny".

I dont like it..it smells terrible and its clumpy

Not a good smell! I don't think that this mascara lasted as long as most! It seemed to get old quick!

This mascara does not live up to its name or expectations...they name the product colossal but this mascara is anything but...more like a colossal dissapointment...it does not create the lengthy look you want and you have to apply it 3 times before you feel satisfied...not to mention it gives off that old mascara smell...overall not very pleased with this product!