I am a traditional pencil eye liner fan. This was the first time I tried anything different. It is a nice shade and doesn't smudge, I like the deesign and it stayed on all day. I'm a fan!

I thought this eyeliner was pretty good. I had one problem, i yawn ALOT in school so i had to keep applying because it would smear under eye. but overall it was a good eyeliner for a good price.

I bought this eyeliner when I lost my Inglot eyeliner (which I still love but costs a bundle). I find that it is really similar to MAC's technakohl eyeliner. It does a great job of staying put without smudging or melting down my eyelids. I also find it really convenient because it doesn't require any sharpening and because it also has a smudge tip on the end of the eyeliner to easily create a dramatic smokey eye look.