I have been using this product for years now. It is by far one of the best eye liner's out there (in my opinion). Even though it's drugstore quality, it feels like a high end product. The cost of the product is really great, more bang for your buck! It glides on easily, no smell and the black color is intense! It's suitable for all skin tones and eye colors. The best thing about this product is that it doesn't smudge and it dry's quickly once you apply it.

I'm very picky when it comes to my eyes and this product is very worth using. I don't like when my liner runs and I was very satisfied with this.

Its great not clumpy goes on evenly i love it.

I like the way. It glides smoothly over the eye

This is the liquid eye liner for girls "who don't do liquid eyeliner good" (Zoolander, anyone?). I am not a coordinated person, and can only close my left eyelid reliably.... my right eyelid? forget it! I need to hold that one down with a finger, in some sort of self-administered wrestling move to get it to lay still while I attempt to draw a straight line on it! Ok, so now that you know my limitations.... I could never use a liquid eye liner in the past, as it would smear all up my (right) lid and then trying to wipe it off turned into a smear fest and I ended up with black smudges everywhere! I gave up pretty quick. But then I discovered this eyeliner. It doesn't have a brush on the end, it's more of a felt pen -type tip on it, and it never seems to have too much liquid on the end, so no ink blobs as you apply, like other liquid liners create. For whatever reason, I am able to apply this liner smoothly on BOTH my eye lids without an issue. If I do make a mistake, it wipes off without a trace. My ONLY qualm about this product is that Maybeline still tests on animals in some form (according to PETA), which bothers me. But, as far as the product itself is concerned - it is amazing.

This is a great product if you have a hard time drawing a straight cat eye. I have a hand tremor, so unless I use tape and then a q-tip after, my cat eye is like a squiggly line. I like this because it doesn't have a tremendous product pick-up, so it's harder to blotch it. It also seems steadier and easier to apply. I do find that if you aren't quick enough or need to go over a line, it dries really fast and you can end up taking OFF product rather than touching it up.

When I apply this in the morning, it stays on up till 3 pm in the afternoon. Then after that I notice it comes off easy without me cleaning it

i found the felt tip wasn't soaking in the liner causing me to have to re-dip the pen multiple times to create one line!
this cause the line to not be fluent and a bit bumpy :(

This eyeliner comes with a felt tip which is my preference when using liquid liner however it doesn't get a lot of product on the tip. After putting it back and shaking it a few times I get more product (but still not enough so this process is repeated a few times). Since there isn't enough product I draw part of my line then when I go to finish or reapply in a certain area, the previously applied liner comes off. It's a pain, takes really long and I did not enjoy it at all! Wouldn't recommend!

Probably worst liquid eyeliner I've ever bought. The tip was scratchy and hurting my eye and I felt like I had to drag it across my eye really hard to even get a faint line of colour out (hi premature wrinkles). I bought the black-brown colour but barely any colour came out no matter how hard I tried to draw it on my eye. Returned it the next day.