I purchased this product after spending about 1/2 at the drug store trying to decide which eye liner to buy instead of my usual Physicians Formula Eye Booster in Ultra Black which the store either didn't carry or they don't make anymore. I really like gel eye liner so when I saw this new product, I figured I'd give it a try. Well, that was a big mistake to deviate from my norm. This eye liner is difficult to apply and smudges so easily. My eyes shortly after applying looked an absolute mess. I realize that it's not waterproof but this is beyond ridiculous how easily this stuff smears and smudges. Definitely will NOT be purchasing this again and do NOT recommend.