My cats do like these but really not as much as other treats that i buy. I really don't think i will buy any more of them because they aren't too keen on them.

Decent ingredients, but don't live up to competing products. Only one my three cats really liked these treats, the rest were indifferent or didn't want them at all. Kinda hard to get them out of the package.

Cat's didn't seem to fancy it. Smelt really bad and made the kitty's breath smell awful.

My cats hated these treats. I would buy them and they would get hard really fast. I purchased on more then one occasion to see if it was just the flavor that my cats hated but it was the product.

None of my 3 cats will eat these. They smell them and walk away. Picky little guys. Higher rating because the price is great, if your cats will actually eat them.