Honestly only reason I didnt enjoy this pen was because it didnt "stay" like the name suggests. everythng else about it was fine, good colour, no bad smell (sometimes liquid ones I have found have harsh smells which in turn bugs my sensitive eyes), really easy to use glides nicely and price wasnt too bad, but didnt stay! only reason I bought it soooo would not suggest.

This is pretty much my favorite eyeliner ever. I love the look of liquid eyeliner, but I suck at applying it. The pen is super easy to use and looks awesome, like a professional did it. It lasts all day for me. I use it pretty much every day now and I have to disagree with the other reviewer, because I've used mine for way more than 5-6 times and it still works perfectly fine. A must-have IMO.

it's a good eye liner for beginner,but when you use it more thn 5 or 6 times its like if it just become dirty. so I didnt use it more tha 5 or 6 time.

I'm more used to the older pencils you sharpen for eyeliners but this I found fairly easy to get used to.

I wish I could smudge it, but that would require my being able to follow the pen tip with a smudger in my other hand immediately. I'm not that coordinated. ;)

I also would prefer it be waterproof. I have allergy eyes, so I often wipe the corners of my eyes. I don't want to find black lines on my fingers after I do that because that means I may have to re-apply. I don't want to apply it more than once a day.

Overall though, its a good product. I think the price is a bit steep, but then, I really haven't bothered with makeup for the better part of the last 15 years so I may be a bit out of the loop.