At first this was my go-to liner.....

The brush is easy to use and it comes in great colours, having used black, black glitter and purple Its at a great price point around $12.00 usually goes on sale as well but it just didnt last long enough, it dries up pretty quick. It does stay put for a few hours, but definitely not long lasting as they claim. Once it starts smudging and if it gets into your eyes it really burns, like bring you to tears burn. I've given up on this liner unless you want fun colours worn for a short time