I hated this mascara, but only for one reason. I prefer a dryer mascara that can be built into lots of volume. This is a lengthening mascara not a building one at all. So basically I was left with a clumpy gluey mess when I tried to achieve nice fat lashes.

This is a good volumizing mascara. I don't like using it on its own because I find it clumps, but I like using it to add color and volume after using a lengthening mascara. For the money though it's definitely not worth it.. I was very disappointed with this mascara.

I wanted to like this mascara but it flakes too much and for a $30 mascara, that's inexcusable.

The good: This mascara is very black, which I love as I always go for the darkest shade available. The formula is more on the dry side. The hour glass brush shape is large and took a while for me to get used to.

The wand picks up a lot of product, so I can see how easy it is for some people to end up with a lot of clumps if they aren't careful. I do like how nice the mascara makes my lashes look; very volumized, lengthened and fluttery. It's nothing extraordinary, it didn't live up to my expectations.

The bad: This mascara is difficult to remove. I always end up with mascara on my lashes, even if I double cleanse.

This mascara also flakes like crazy. By the end of the day I always have a whole bunch of fall out which is very odd for me. Mascara rarely flakes on me.

All in all: this mascara provides a nice effect but it's nothing special, just an okay mascara with a huge price tag and flaking issues.

Most people rave about this mascara. I don't find it anything special, but it works great at separating, lengthening and darkening my lashes. Doesn't clump or flake

I found that it doesn't hold the curl, and although it gives great volume, it doesn't add any length, flakes a lot on me and it dries too quickly (considering the price)!

I did like this mascara but within about two hours i have lash lines above my eyes, just under my eyebrows. The mascara literally melts off and leaves little lines (but I guess that means its doing its job at creating long lashes!) I hate waterproof mascara so I'm stuck with watching out for these lash lines. I do like the brush, it has little separators in it that work really well for my eyelashes. Expensive though

Like most mascaras I end up having flakes under my eyes within a few hours of using. I also did not like that the formula clumps very easily.

At first sight, this mascara is really amazing.. i loved the way it made my lashes look full and long and luscious. But, half way through the day this mascara flakes on me every single time i wear it. It flakes all over my face after about 5-6 hours of wear, which is really disappointing to me... especially for the price.

Not a huge fan!

It certainly makes my lashes stand out, and more visible.
I find it makes my eyelashes look clumpy, and those clumps do tend to dry up and flake off within about half hour of application, leaving specks of mascara all over my cheeks... I could certainly do without that.