I love this liner for getting that perfect smudgy, smoky eye. I only use it on my top lash line though, because I find it's not as pigmented when placed in my waterline.

I got a sample of this liner in my Ipsy bag and immediately fell in love with it! Creamy, easy to apply and little to no smudging

I absolutely love this product! I took a leap of faith after being frustrated with my regular eye liner and I'm never going back to the old liner again. The UD liner actually stays all day long, I don't have to worry about fixing it every hour like other brands, and it gives me great bold colour. Normally eye liner was a drug store brand but this is well worth the price because it actually stays on my face, even in the hot summer sun.

I've had this pencil in grey, purple and black-- and I like them all! They run smoothly on the eye. My one negative response would be that they dry up quite easily. Make sure you have that cap on tight!

Stays on well and is easy to apply. Very pigmented with many different colours!

Tried this eyeliner out for the first time. I love how easily it goes on and love all the different colours you can get. It definitely lasts all-day and there's very little smudge. It's a little pricey for an eyeliner, but it's definitely a good one.

I really wanted to at least like these pencils. I've tried 8 of the colors and they all smudged on me in less than two hours no matter how I tried to wear them. They never seemed to "set". The colors are beautiful and vibrant other than that these were a total flop for me.

This is one of the few eyeliners that does not smudge on me. I received this as a sample and have never looked back. It goes on creamy, stays in the waterline and also smudges out well. Love it!

This pencil is sooooo creamy and pigmented! I don't purchase it in the basic shades because I feel Rimmel makes better eyeliners for basic colours like black and brown. My favourite is the shade LSD, it's sooo pretty, it's like a shimmery bright blue and I also have the green olive one, but I don't know the shade name because it's just a stub I've used it so much. Try a tester at Sephora, you'll fall in love!

amazing this is my favorite eyeliner by far amazing for your waterline and lids because it glides perfectly smooth and pigment is bold